Your Guide to Test Driving Cars In the Quest of Finding a Quiet Vehicle

2
15

wheelgrip

Are you dissatisfied with your current car in terms of its excessive interior noise level; be it road noise, wind noise, engine noise and/or miscellaneous rattles and squeaks? And do you feel a bit confused as to how to best find a quieter car that suits your needs?

I would like to share some of my learnings from having test driven a wide range of cars with the objective of assessing the relative noise levels inside the cabin of the cars.

Here are some key learnings:

Do research and come up with a well-informed shortlist

Read articles and independent tests about the relative quietness/noisiness of different cars. One thing to really watch out for is that most new car reviews are based on the journalist driving the car on very smooth road surfaces, which will generate substantially lower decibel ratings compared to driving on rougher, more ‘real-world’ surfaces. Talk to car salespeople and automotive journalists about the relative noisiness based on driving the car on more regular surfaces. Ask friends and acquaintances about their experiences. And arrive at a shortlist of cars to test drive. Make sure to pay attention to that different technical platforms may differ substantially with regards to the interior noise level. Hence, the specific model year of the cars you test drive are of high relevance.

Identify comparable cars in your area to test drive

You will want the cars to be as comparable as possible in order to be able to make an informed buying decision, so if you are looking for a quiet car, try to find vehicles that have as small wheels as possible for that particular model.

If you e.g. wish to compare the BMW 5 Series to the Mercedes E-Class, it will be tricky if the BMW has 17-inch wheels on and the Mercedes 18-inch wheels. Unavoidably, it will be likely for the cars to have different tire/tyre models on, which in itself will make a noise comparison tricky (tires/tyres may actually have quite a large effect on the level of road noise generated inside the cabin), but at least try to compare cars with the same wheel size since the wheel size most commonly have a direct effect on the level of road noise.

I have seen cases though where a car was quieter with 17-inch wheels and a quiet tire/tyre model on, than with 16-inch wheels and a noisy tire/tyre on. Which goes to show that the dynamics between wheel size and tire/tyre model is important to take into account.

I’m located in Sweden, and since our market’s service-mindedness is absolutely lousy NOT ONE car dealer has offered me the option of changing the wheels of a car that I wished to test drive. But if you are living in a more customer-friendly market, and you really would like to test a particular Volvo V70 with 16-inch wheels instead of the 18-inch that are mounted on the car, then ask if the dealer can be so kind to make a switch before your test drive. You could even offer a small sum of money for the time it would take them to switch wheels.

Focus both on the objective and subjective interior noise level

I recommend you to bring a sound meter with you so that you can record objective measurements of the decibel/dB level of the noise. If the sound meter does not also pick up the actual frequency range of the sound, then the decibel number will not tell the entire story.

But that’s why you need to combine the objective measurement with actively listening to the noise with your own ears. It varies between inidividuals which types of noise (on which frequency ranges) that are perceived as aggravating and unacceptable, so each person has to make a judgment call as to how he/she perceives it in a given car.

It may be tricky to evaluate the noise both via sound meter measurements and subjectively via your ears, so I highly recommend you to bring a friend to the test drives. Have your friend sit in the backseat and measure the decibel level in three different places – in the middle at the front of the cabin, around the left ear of the driver (the right ear if you are in a market with left-hand traffic) and in the backseat area.

Do the sound measurement at idle engine speed as well as at a few different speed levels including varying intensity of acceleration and at full throttle.

Test drive the cars on the same roads

This one can be tricky since the car dealers you will be visiting may be located far from each other, but in order to really be able to assess the differences between different cars you will want to drive them on the same type of road surface (with the same types of smoothness/roughness) and in similar wind conditions. The reason being that the actual road surface can have a tremendous impact on the level of road noise generated and the wind conditions can lead to strongly varying levels of wind noise.

The best strategy is to try to test drive cars on a mixture of smoother and coarser/rougher surfaces so that you will get a real feel for how the car will behave in different situations. If you don’t consider this and only test drive on a smooth road surface, then you might end up owning a car with painfully excessive road noise as soon as the wheels hit a coarser/rougher road surface.

If you are unable to test drive the cars on the same roads, drive around with your own car to be able to assess the level of coarseness prior to the test drive. Since you know your own car’s behavior on different surfaces, you will be able to get a feel for the types of roads you will be test driving on. If your car is noisy, then even better, because it will be more sensitive in terms of noise level when the road surface changes.

I hope these pointers can be of some help to you in your search for a quieter ride.

Special thanks to Rossi for sharing his experience.

If you have additional test drive insights not covered here, please let us know and comment below. We would love to hear from you!

To learn more about cars and sound/noise, get your copy of the Quiet Cars eBook – Your Guide to a Quieter Ride – plus join the Quiet Cars online community.

Image: Nate Steiner

Quiet Cars - An Introductory Guide to a Quieter Ride (eBook and online community)
  • Michal

    Hi there. First of all, I love the website. It is astonishing to me that the quietness of the cabin is not addressed more by the professionals who review new cars. Thus, having a home site I can go to to read about noise levels in car cabins is great.
    Having said the above, I am here because I am hoping for some feedback. I am currently in the market for a new car and I like the 2013 Audi A4 (petrol engine). The car is really quiet when it comes to the engine noise (sometimes it is not clear if the engine is on!). However, when I test drove it on the highway there was a substantial wind noise at ca. 120 km/h. One thing I noticed is that the noise coming from other cars on the highway was also annoyingly noticeable. Any thoughts on Audi A4? Maybe I test drove a lemon? Is it normal to have wind noise in a car of this class? Maybe I am expecting too much?

    I also tested a 2013 BMW 328i and the effect was quite similar. Also, Volvo
    S60 showed similar (perhaps a small bit lower) levels of wind noise. In
    my mind cars like Audi or BMW should be QUIET. It does not seem to be
    the case. Do you guys have some idea about sedans or hatchbacks that are available in Europe that are quiet?
    Thanks!
    Michal

    • http://magnuskahler.com/ Magnus Kahler

      Hi Michal! Thanks for the comment and I’m very sorry about the late response. Have you already bought a car by now?

      I’d say that you’re expecting too much in terms of the wind noise. Even the premium car brands generate a lot of wind noise at highway speeds. HOWEVER, if you’re especially sensitive in terms of wind noise, you should look for brands that offer laminated windows. I’m not sure about which particular brands that offer laminated windows but I know Volvo does and it’s standard or an option for the latest model year of the Mercedes-Benz E Class.

      I think one ought to be able to expect ALL premium brands to offer laminated or extra thick windows, AT LEAST as an option.

      If you’re buying a used car, it is also worth exploring whether you can achieve reduced noise by maintaining and/or exchanging the door seals. For more info, check out: http://elevatingsound.com/causes-of-wind-noise-and-how-to-keep-the-noise-down-by-maintaining-your-door-seals/

      Let us know how things go and tell us about your experience with the vehicle you end up buying.